Scam artist or struggling hero?

On Tuesday, July 14, the Washington Journalism and Media Conference traveled to the Smithsonian Institute to view the air and space exhibits, but encountered a more intriguing character. A middle aged African American man, claiming to be a retired United States Marine, approached the students of the conference with a plea for help. The question running through all the student's minds was, "Does this guy have a legitimate need?"
To answer that question, one would have to take the information they were given and analyze that, as well as the man's appearance and sincerity. The stranger in question was a clean individual wearing a red polo and blue jeans, both of which seemed relatively new. He also came with a prepared story about his family's current situation, their financial need, and his service in the military. Within his speech, he made sure to include humor to capture the young audience and religious references to gain their trust.
By taking a step back and realizing how well he put himself together, regardless of his middle class image, it would make viewers assume that the man was simply an average actor with an eye for gullible kids. Still, there's the question of ethics. If this man is truly in need of financial assistance, who are we to question his sincerity or wardrobe? Don't "they" always say that people must look the part to get the job? Anyone could be in danger of losing their home and still have decent clothes.
One must never assume, yet one must never be to quick to believe. In the case of the "U.S. Marine," every student had to make their own judgement and choose their own path. Either way, no student was harmed by gifting the man with a few dollars, and every student seemed to enjoy the man's charm. They may never know the man's true identity, but some do have the happiness of knowing they helped someone while others are proud that they didn't fall into another scam.
The only person negatively affected by the occurrence has to be the man himself. As many believe, if he really is an actor, he will either be brought down by guilt or karma. For instance, money for booze has the potential to just get him arrested, or in a fatal collision. If he was truly sincere, than there's no further reason to discuss this issue.